PRILA at the European Society of Criminology e-conference 2020

This year’s European Society of Criminology’s Annual conference took place online 10-11 September 2020. Initially planned to be hosted in Bucharest, the Romanian organisers had accepted the task to arrange – together with the ESC Secretariat – the online meeting via one of the many platforms that today enable exchange between all of us affected by the ongoing pandemic. A stringent programme was developed along the existing thematic working groups of the ESC by their chairs, who each organised a stream of panels. More than 700 participants attended – rather: connected to – 116 panels and it was good to see colleagues at least on screen.

The PRILA project found a home in the ESC Working Group on Prisons (https://escnewsletter.org/newsletter/2019-1/esc-prison-working-group) in the panel “Complaints, Rights and Oversight Bodies”. Sophie discussed ‘Patterns and correlates of familiarity with prison oversight bodies among prisoners’, which outlined degrees of familiarity among different groups within the prison population of oversight bodies. Sarah explored ‘The power of prisoner complaint’ as perceived by senior staff. Christine looked at ‘Rules, rights and ethics in prisons as perceived by Senior Staff’ in German prisons (abstracts provided below). The session was completed by Ergul Celiksoy from the University of Nottingham who introduced his research on the ‘Execution of the European Court’s Judgments in Prisoner’s Right to Vote Cases.’ The combination of papers proved to be stimulating (despite our panel being the last of a very long day!), as the audience engaged in a lively discussion. This discussion touched upon the acceptance of court rulings in prison matters (both in the case of the decisions European Court of Human Rights and their impact on national policy, and in domestic cases of judicial oversight); the question of a potential preventive effect of institutional prison oversight and prisoner complaints; and more generally upon aspects of discretion in the work of prison officers. After giving some first insights into our project’s work last year at the ESC conference in Ghent, this panel kept the ‘European Criminology Family’ up-to-date with the PRILA progress and found an attentive audience.

Guess who? Patterns and correlates of familiarity with prison oversight bodies among prisoners (Sophie van der Valk, Eva Aizpurua, & Mary Rogan, Trinity College Dublin)

Oversight bodies play an important role in the protection of prisoners’ rights. While these bodies are seen as widely beneficial demonstrated through the proliferation of bodies and international treaties surrounding them, there is limited research examining them. This study sought to address this gap in the existing literature, by identifying unique profiles of prisoners based on their familiarity with prison oversight bodies. In addition, the relationship between profiles and key factors (personal characteristics, sentence-related variables, and those related to life in prison) was examined using multinomial regression. Participants were 508 males randomly selected from three medium-security prisons in Ireland. Data were collected between November of 2018 and February of 2019 using self-administered surveys. Latent class analysis revealed  four subgroups of prisoners characterized by distinct patterns of awareness and contact with prison oversight bodies: 1) Low familiarity (43.9%), 2) High awareness with low contact (26.4 %), 3) High familiarity with the Visiting Committees but low with other oversight bodies (14.4%%), and 4) High familiarity (15.4%). Notably, the largest group was the low familiarity group, and few prisoners belonged to the high familiarity group. Nationality, sentence length, confidence in staff and complaint usage were linked to class membership. The results of this study point to the importance of increasing awareness of oversight bodies among prisoners in general. Also, differences in the composition of the classes provide additional information to target policy and prevention strategies. These findings are of interest to those working on complaints/grieving procedures, but also more broadly to those interested in how prison oversight is experienced by those these structures are designed to protect.

‘Imagine… A Person Listening to You?’: The Power of Prisoner Complaint (Sarah Curristan & Mary Rogan, Trinity College Dublin)

Prison work is a profession that ascribes its occupants a considerable degree of power over those in their charge. Prisoner complaint mechanisms are a vital means by which prisoners can express grievances regarding prison conditions, treatment, or decisions that affect their experience while in custody. As such, the complaints system is one forum through which the prison as an institution can be called to account by prisoners; it is a means for the disempowered to exert a check – however minimal – on the powerful and to express perceived injustice. Drawing on interviews with prison managers from the Irish Prison Service, this research explores the concept of complaint as a form of power. Through a discussion of responsibilities for handling complaints, this paper will describe the stark contrast of perspectives shared by prison staff. For some, complaints are recognised as an essential means for prisoners to voice dissatisfaction, but for others complaints are viewed through the lens of their destructive potential. This perception is one that persists despite the low rate of complaints that are successfully upheld. Further research on how complaints are treated by prison authorities is required, particularly an examination of the efficacy of such procedures. This research presents a starting point for such discussion in examining staff attitudes to complaint.

“One always looks for a compromise…” – Rules, rights and ethics in prisons as perceived by Senior Staff  (Christine Morgenstern, Sarah Curristan, Eva Aizpurua & Mary Rogan, Trinity College Dublin)

German prison legislation is praised as comprehensive, based on a fundamental rights approach (van Zyl Smit/Snacken 2009) and prisons are ‘characterized by a highly legalized culture’ (van Zyl Smit 2010). The legislation therefore serves as the frame of reference for all actions and decisions taken in prisons; a special court has the power to review them, if a prisoner appeals to the law. Despite this approach, longstanding criticism refers to the fact that many of the regulations still leave a great deal of discretion to prison staff (Feest/Lesting 2009) and judicial review does not remedy this unpredictability. A more recent initiative calls for a discussion on professional ethics in prisons that could help in situations where the law does not give clear guidance (Becka 2015; 2016; Justizvollzugsbeauftragter NRW 2017). Little is known, however, how senior staff themselves deal with these questions. Drawing on data gained from 24 in-depth interviews conducted in four German prisons between May and December 2019 and a paper survey distributed in February 2020,  this contribution explores how senior staff is guided by the legal prescriptions, how far they see them as legitimate and ethical, what they miss and what else enables them ‘to do the right thing’.

Ask an Expert: Managing prisons during the COVID-19 pandemic, special guest blog with Caron McCaffrey, Director General of the Irish Prison Service.

In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, prisons pose a particularly challenging environment in which to prevent the spread of disease. Next in our Ask An Expert series, PRILA had the opportunity to ask Caron McCaffrey, Director General of the Irish Prison Service, about her experience in overseeing Irish prisons during COVID-19, and the Prison Service response to COVID-19.

  1. The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic has affected prisons as it has affected other parts of our community; organisations such as the WHO and Penal Reform International have highlighted that prisons and places of detention require effective protective and preventative measures in order to help control the spread of the virus. Are there any aspects of the prison environment that makes management of COVID-19 particularly challenging?

Preventing the spread of infectious diseases in prisons is both a public health concern and a human rights imperative. Prisoners retain their human rights during incarceration, including the right to health, the right to life, freedom from torture and ill treatment, and freedom from discrimination. These rights impose a legal duty of care on the State to protect the lives, health and well-being of persons deprived of their liberty.

Prisons represent high-risk environments for the transmission of diseases and spread of infection due to the nature of the prison environment and its operations which includes:

  • The Prison Service is home or place of work for in excess of 7000 people living and working together in proximity, which supports the transmission of infection.
  • Facilities (such as showers, toilets, tables) and equipment (such as gym equipment) are shared.
  • The risk that prisoners may not undertake good hygiene practices.
  • Underlying health or addiction issues may mean that prisoners are more at risk in relation to infectious diseases.
  • Prisoners typically have a greater burden of disease than the general population, including chronic disease, blood borne virus infections and TB.
  • As well as prisons and staff, the prison estates are frequented by a wide range of members of the public on a daily basis, any of whom could transmit an infection either inward or outward from the prison. Members of the public accessing the prison estate include:
    • Visitors
    • Healthcare professionals
    • Teachers
    • Social workers
    • Service-delivery personnel

The high-risk area identified in respect of the spread of COVID-19 is through the people from outside the prison estate entering the gates. Controlling this risk necessitates an enhanced process to mitigate against the threat of the infection coming into the prisons.

The prisons have continued to work at an average of 85% occupancy during the pandemic which means that the difficulties associated with social distancing have been at the forefront of planning, given that over 52% of prisoners share cells (on a double, triple or 4 man occupancy basis).

  1. Ireland has been notably successful in managing COVID-19, with no cases reported among people in custody so far. Can you provide some examples of how the Prison Service has responded to the current crisis, particularly with respect to vulnerable groups such as the elderly or those with underlying health conditions? And, perhaps reflect on the benefits and challenges associated with these strategies?

Guided by the advice of the National Public Health Emergency Team (NPHET), and consistent with the prison specific guidance for the management of Covid-19 issued by the World Health Organisation (WHO) and guidance of the Council of Europe.  Measures introduced have included:

  • The introduction of a basic health check, including taking of temperatures for all persons, including staff, entering prisons from 29 March;
  • Suspension of physical family visits, replaced by the introduction of video visits;
  • Quarantining for 14 days of all newly committed prisoners, in order to reduce the risk that a new committal who might be incubating the virus could spread Covid-19 to the general prison population;
  • Isolation of suspected case or prisoner with symptoms to prevent the risk of transmission of infection;
  • “Cocooning” of vulnerable prisoners including all prisoners aged 70 years or more or those that are deemed medically vulnerable;
  • Comprehensive training for IPS staff and the provision of appropriate Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) across the prison estate;
  • Strong communication with staff and prisoners, including two prison newsletters published weekly and regular Covid-19 information leaflets for prisoners and newsletters for staff regarding actions taken; and
  • Establishment of a robust contract tracing model which has been acknowledged by the World Health Organisation as best practice.

The Irish Prison Service has representation as a member of the vulnerable persons sub-group on the National Public Health Emergency Team (“NPHET”) and we have worked closely with the nationally co-ordinated response to the epidemic from an early stage. Prisoners are categorised as a vulnerable group facing greater risks partly due to underlying health issues with currently approximately 400 prisoners in the system aged 55 years or older, with 130 who are over 65 year of age and many who would have very complex healthcare needs.

At the start of March, we formed an Emergency Response Planning Team to formulate contingency plans, review policies and procedures, implementing actions, developing the necessary structures, and communicate in relation to the challenges posed by COVID-19 with the aim of:

  • Blocking COVID-19 from entering the prison environment;
  • Early detection of any possible case of COVID 19 in a prisoner or staff member; and,
  • Prevention of the spread of COVID 19 should a case in the prison be confirmed.

From a very early stage we put structures and systems in place to establish areas of responsibility, prescribed methods of communication and sources of information to ensure that Government decisions and Public Health advice was implemented in full, interpreted to be successful and consistently applied across the prisons system.

The preventative and responsive measures to prevent COVID-19 entering the prison which we put in place included:

Temporary Release of low risk prisoners – we sought to mitigate the risks associated with overcrowding and reduce the number of prisoners in our prisons. This included the granting of temporary release to low risk prisoners, who were assessed on a case by case basis. As a result, the number of prisoners in custody in our prisons has been reduced sufficiently to allow for an effective infection control regime which initially included physical distancing but now incorporates necessary cocooning and the temporary short-term quarantining of prisoners.

Health Checks – we have a proactive approach to ensure the early detection of any possible case of COVID-19.  Critical to the IPS strategy to manage Covid-19 has been the early identification of prisoners who display possible symptoms. Prisoners displaying symptoms are seen by the prison healthcare team who make a clinical decision whether the person needs to isolate, and this is informed by the advice provided by Public Health/HSE.

Visitor Restrictions – In managing the risks and challenges during this pandemic the highest risk area identified in respect of the spread of COVID-19 in the prisons was through people from outside the prison estate entering the gates. We therefore took the early and prudent decision to restrict visits to prisons in mid-March and fully suspended family visits on 27th March 2020.

Screening – We are implementing a health screening protocol which includes a temperature check for all persons entering our prisons since 29th March. The question-based assessment was devised to assist the identification of persons who may be at risk of transmitting the virus across the prison estate. People who do not pass the screening, do not enter the prison and are advised to contact their doctor.

Quarantining & Cocooning – following public health guidelines, we introduced procedures to place those prisoners who are over the age of 70 or have underlying medical conditions or are newly committed to prison are cocooning or in quarantine.

Prisoners who present as symptomatic and are awaiting test results are monitored by clinical staff daily and receive appropriate care.

  1. This has been a particularly stressful and demanding period for people both living and working in prison. Can you share with us some thoughts on how both prisoners and staff have been coping with the pandemic?

 

We are very conscious of the impact during this time on people’s mental health and are acutely aware of the supportive role families and friends play in prisoners’ efforts to rehabilitate themselves while in prison and prepare themselves for life in the community after release from prison.

In acknowledgement of the impact of visitor restrictions on prisoners and to mitigate against this impact, we introduced a number of initiatives across the whole estate in the last number of weeks.

  • All prisoners were provided with additional and extended length of time phone calls.
  • Video phone facilities were installed across all prisons to allow for video-calls with families. We have had positive feedback from both prisoners and their families on this endeavor. It has provided the opportunity to see family and friends in the comfort and security of their own home environment; it saves time, cost and effort involved in traveling to the prison, particularly for children, elderly and people suffering from ill-health and provides opportunities to show changes to a home e.g. renovations, a new pet, new furniture, the garden.
  • Electronic Funds Transfer / An Post Bill Pay to allow families to provide credit to prisoners for the tuckshop, the Irish Prison Service has put in place cashless transfer facilities.

In addition to the family video calls, rehabilitating prisoners for release to their families has been provided for in the extension of video link and phone calls to medical and rehabilitative services in the prisons and to attend court.

In the absence of direct contact from people outside the community, the Irish Prison Service also set up a dedicated team to co-ordinate the communication of information about the pandemic and its impact to prisoners. Staff involved in providing prisoner services and Red Cross Volunteers produce a weekly newsletter to speak directly to prisoners and keep them informed of all the important messages that they need to be aware to allow an informed dialogue to take place between prisoners and their families.

There is also a special bespoke newsletter for prisoners who are in quarantine or cocooning with tailored messaging for them.  Prisoners who are in quarantine or cocooning can use the prisoner phone system to access prisoner services from Psychology, Chaplaincy, resettlement or Merchants Quay. This system is being reviewed to ensure that it meets requirements and to also assess if it the service can be improved further.

Communications to staff and prisoners has been critical throughout this period. A comprehensive and bespoke communication campaign was implemented to support timely and clear distribution of information and raise awareness. Posters, floor markings, information leaflets and tailored newsletters for staff and prisoners are published and distributed to ensure the correct information is available to staff and prisoners at all times and to raise awareness of supports and services available. The communication of clear simple messages, mirroring what happens in the community around issues such as social distancing, respiratory etiquette and good hygiene practices has contributed to maintaining a COVID19 free prison environment.  The Irish Red Cross volunteers through the established Community Based Health and First Aid (CBHFA) prison programme have been pivotal in communicating and supporting people in our custody. The Irish Prison Service continues to examine cost effective ways of enhancing communication through the use of existing services and infrastructure.

We have increased our communications to staff providing them with information in advance of measures being put in place and the operational impact of same.  We have distilled information from Public Health and the centre to ensure staff have clarity on where to get further advice.  We issued FAQs to staff on the COVID-19 pandemic and guidance relating to what this means in the workplace.  We ensured that our frontline staff were part of the priority group for testing in line with the provision there for healthcare workers.

 

  1. We have seen many innovative steps taken by the Prison Service in response to the virus – including the utilisation of temporary release, the introduction of technology to support online visits, and phone privileges to access additional supports for some prisoners. Can you share some thoughts on how it might be possible to continue these practices after the threat of COVID-19 has subsided?

We are currently in a stabilization and unwinding phase and are exploring what and how some of the initiatives that we have implemented will continue. It will include continuing to work closely with the Department of Justice and our colleagues in the Criminal Justice Sector and investing in more technology and resources to support continued delivery of additional services.

  1. As the government takes steps to re-open the country, we’ve seen phased plans for the easing of restrictions. What are the challenges that lie ahead for the Prison Service? And, are there any lessons learned from the response to COVID-19 that may shape Irish prisons going forward?

We have many measures in place that have supported us in controlling the spread of COVID-19 in our prisons. As society now re-opens, we need to determine how we maintain control of the risk of the spread of infection in a closed environment, while maintaining good order, health, safety and security in the prison. One of our biggest challenges is the easing of visitor restrictions while controlling the spread of infection among staff, prisoners, visitors and the wider community due to increased exposure and minimizing the impact on vulnerable prisoners with addiction problems.

There are many lessons learned in relation to the importance of communication and managing the expectation of prisoner’s families. These will help shape how we engage holistically with stakeholders going forward.

Ask an Expert: Campaigning for Prisoners’ rights during the COVID-19 pandemic, with Irish Penal Reform Trust

In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, prisons pose a particularly challenging environment in which to prevent the spread of disease. Next in our Ask an Expert series, PRILA asks Fíona Ní Chinnéide, Executive Director of Irish Penal Reform Trust (IPRT) about IPRT’s work, with a specific focus on advocating for prisoners’ rights during the COVID-19 pandemic. Established in 1994, IPRT is a leading NGO in Ireland dedicated to advancing the rights of people in prison and penal reform. Given the unique challenges that COVID-19 poses for prisons, we appreciate the insight and reflections Fíona provides here.

 

Questions:

  1. Ireland has been notably successful in managing COVID-19, with no cases reported thus far amongst people in prison. This is in sharp contrast to other jurisdictions, such as the UK. What do you think is unique or particularly significant to the approach taken by the Irish Prison Service to combat the threat of COVID-19?

 

Early action on reducing prison crowding was one of the most significant preventative actions taken in Ireland, in stark contrast with England and Wales in particular. From the moment the pandemic was declared, the UN, Council of Europe, WHO and others were insistent that the release of prisoners was essential to prevent COVID-19 from “rampaging” through crowded prisons, given the difficulties of adhering to public health guidelines on social distancing, sanitation and hygiene within prisons, coupled with the compromised health that generally characterises prison populations. Ireland responded by releasing over 10% of the prison population over a four-week period from mid-March to mid-April 2020, and numbers have continued to fall slowly due to a decrease in remand and sentenced committals from the Courts. There were 3,672 people in prison on Friday 19th June 2020; this is the lowest figure since 2017.

 

The majority of men and women released in response to the threat of COVID-19 were serving short sentences of less than 12 months; an additional number had fewer than 6 months remaining on their sentence. Importantly, people weren’t simply let out: prison service staff and community-based organisations worked closely to ensure planned structured releases from prison, and prevent release into homelessness. There have reportedly been very few recalls to prison, which underscores just what can be achieved by joined-up collaborative working – something that IPRT, the Interagency Group for a Fairer and Safer Ireland, the Penal Policy Review Group and others had called for over many, many years.

 

Another key element has been good communications between prison staff and prisoners. The Irish Red Cross prisoner volunteer programme, in particular, has played a critical role through the peer-to-peer sharing of information about COVID-19, helping to foster an environment of trust and co-operation within the prisons. This is essential as COVID-19 restrictions have resulted in particularly harsh prison conditions, including long hours spent in cells and reduced access to fresh air, gym, yards, workshops, and, in some cases, no access to showers. No prison schools are open, psychology and addictions services are by telephone, and there have been no in-person visits since end March 2020. The success of keeping COVID-19 out of prisons has not been without impact on the physical and mental health and wellbeing of people in prison.

 

  1. This has been a particularly stressful and demanding period for people living and working in prison, but also for the family members of people in prison. Can you share with us some thoughts on how COVID-19-related restrictions have impacted families, for better or worse?

 

Families are often described as the “hidden victims” of imprisonment, and the burden of having a family member in prison is significant at all times. In response to COVID-19 risks, children have not been allowed visit prisons since mid-March, and all in-person visits have been suspended since the end of March. This means that around 6,000 children in Ireland have not hugged their parent in prison in almost four months. It has been a deeply worrying time for families concerned about the health of their loved one in prison, and for people in prison feeling helpless concern for their families outside. At the same time, for some families, it has been experienced as a break from having to travel sometimes long distances at significant financial expense for what can be a short and unsatisfactory visit with their loved one.

 

Innovations introduced by the Irish Prison Service include the ability to lodge money electronically into the family member’s prison account, without having to travel to the prison, and video calls. The introduction of video calls has not been without hiccups and frustrations for families, but the IPS has dedicated resources including a helpline to assist families. IPRT has long called for video calls to be made available for people whose families cannot visit, whether for reasons of cost, immobility or being in another country. However, it is critical that video visits are retained as an option and not as a replacement for in-person visits when life returns to ‘normal’ in future. IPRT is concerned that security reasons – reducing one entry point for contraband into prison – should not over-ride rights to family contact or for a child to have meaningful contact with their parent.

 

  1. IPRT has been active in calling on the government to take measures to reduce the prison population, both before and in response to the threat of the COVID-19 pandemic. Some of these measures have been reflected in the government’s response including the utilisation of temporary release, the introduction of technology to support online visits, and increased phone privileges to access additional supports for some prisoners. What steps is IPRT taking to ensure the IPS continues these practices after the threat of COVID-19 has subsided?

 

Although IPRT has so far resisted saying “I told you so” (externally, at least!) it remains the case that if the actions and recommendations IPRT had made over many years had been implemented previously, the prison system would have been starting from a different place in March 2020 when the pandemic was declared. Prisons would have been operating within capacity, video calls would already have been available, there would have been a seamless transition to e-learning when the closure of prison schools was announced, and more. We welcome that so many positive reforms have been achieved in such a short time; however, it should not have taken a global pandemic for this to happen – the evidence was already there to support these reforms.

 

A key challenge for IPRT now is to ensure that we don’t return to “business as usual” as the threat of COVID 19 recedes, and to ensure that good practices are retained. For example, if 450 people serving short sentences could be safely released from prison at short notice, the question we must ask ourselves is why it was necessary to imprison these people in the first place? We know community punishments are cheaper, often more effective and less damaging than short custodial sentences, so it is critical that Ireland does not return to over-reliance on prison as punishment as we emerge from the crisis. Research, data, and evaluation will be key to retaining positive practices.

 

To this end, a key objective for IPRT this year is to capture the positive reforms that have been implemented, document how these reforms were achieved, outline and measure the longer-term benefits of the reforms to wider community and society, and then advocate, engage and raise awareness across all stakeholders – from policy-makers to legal professions, from legislators to the wider general public. The centre-piece of this work will be the 2020 edition of our annual Progress in the Penal System report, further enhanced through engagement, seminars, media and all the usual activities that IPRT undertakes.

 

  1. As the government takes steps to re-open the country, we’ve seen phased plans for the easing of restrictions. What are the challenges ahead for the prison service? And, are there any lessons learned from the response to COVID-19 that may shape Irish Prisons going forward?

 

Restrictions that were introduced in line with public health guidance on residential settings should now be eased in line with the same guidance, in order to reduce the significant negative impact of the measures on men and women in prison – these impacts have included long hours locked up in cell, vastly reduced access to services and regimes, and long periods without access to exercise in fresh air. However, managing the expectations of people in prison and their families on the outside as Ireland slowly re-opens, especially around in-person visits and for people who are cocooning within prison, will be challenging – particularly if there is any resurgence of the virus in the community.

 

Some specific challenges that lie ahead for the Irish Prison Service include:

 

  1. Responding to the long-term mental health impacts of what has been de facto solitary confinement for a large cohort of the prison population, including increased demand for psychology services from a service that was already over-stretched and under-resourced. Along with individual interventions and supports, prison psychology services will have to catch up on offence-related programmes that were paused during the crisis.
  2. Maintaining social distancing while operating above the prison capacity levels that would allow for single-cell occupancy of cells. In particular, prison numbers must be carefully monitored as the Courts gradually re-open to prevent a surge in prison committals, whether on remand or under sentence; this can be achieved by a presumption in favour of community-based sanctions as a response to less serious offending and enshrining in law is the principle of imprisonment as a sanction of last resort, reserved for serious offences.
  3. Preventing release into homelessness in the longer term. One of the silver linings of the crisis has been the availability of longer-term (by which we mean not night-to-night) accommodation for people on release from prison, including supported accommodation options. This requires sustained investment and strong inter-agency co-operation. Reverting to releasing people into homelessness while the virus remains in the community, at any level, would be extremely concerning.

 

  1. The importance of external monitoring and oversight of prisons. The absence of published inspection reports on prisons means that we have little insight on current prison conditions and the extent to which the human rights of people in prison have been respected during the pandemic. This is a concern.
  2. The importance of good communication. In particular, the role that the Irish Red Cross Prisoner Volunteer Programme played in peer-to-peer communication and working alongside prison staff has been key to the success of keeping COVID-19 out of prisons in Ireland. Empowering and giving agency to prisoners was essential to this success, and forms a good basis for increased opportunities for prisoner groups in future.
  3. The recognition of the continuum between prison health and public health, and the inclusion of the Irish Prison Service Executive Clinical Lead in the NPHET Vulnerable Persons Subgroup has played an important role in recognising that prisoners are part of the wider community, and public health can learn from prison health in this instance.

 

In summary, Ireland’s prison system was in crisis at the beginning of March 2020 when the pandemic was declared, with rising levels of overcrowding, people sleeping on mattresses on prison floors, and ever-increasing numbers of people detained on remand. Early decisive action by the Irish Prison Service and the Department of Justice & Equality, including the reduction of the prison population by over 10%, helped keep COVID 19 out of prisons. The pandemic brought urgency and the political will to act across a number of key areas, including release of people imprisoned on short sentences, and improved access to health and housing in the community. This experience shows us what is possible when there is political will for action and reform, and IPRT looks forward to building on this in future.

 

Ask an Expert: Monitoring of Prisons during the Covid-19 pandemic, with Patricia Gilheaney, Inspector of Prisons, Ireland.

In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, prisons pose a particularly challenging environment in which to prevent the spread of disease. Therefore, the oversight of prisons is an important strategy to ensure rights are respected and that efforts taken to prevent and minimize spread of disease are necessary, proportionate, respectful of human dignity and restricted in time. In Ireland, the Office of the Inspector of Prisons, led by Chief Inspector Patricia Gilheaney, has been instrumental to monitoring the prison response to the threat of COVID-19. The Office of the Inspector of Prisons has been a statutory body in Ireland since 2007 and is responsible for monitoring all of the prisons in Ireland, as well as investigating deaths in custody. PRILA had the great opportunity to ask Chief Inspector Gilheaney about her experience of oversight in relation to Irish prison responses to Covid-19, and how her role has adapted to ensure that the rights of those in custody are protected during this time. Given that prison oversight during the pandemic is a significant challenge, we appreciate the insight and reflections Inspector Gilheaney provides here about her experience.

  1. Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, organisations such as the WHO and Penal Reform International have highlighted the urgent need to implement effective protections and preventative measures in places of detention. What makes prison a challenging environment when it comes to the management of COVID-19?

There is copious evidence regarding the prevalence and spread of infectious diseases in congregated settings.  Prisons provide an ideal setting for the spread of such diseases due to large numbers of people living in congregated cramped conditions. A high proportion of people in prisons are also considered to be vulnerable due to their age and poor health status. Therefore there are challenges in providing single cell accommodation, social distancing measures, clean environments, access to meaningful interactions with others, visits from family members; access to education/work/training.  The ‘usual’ routine in a prison is completely changed very quickly and frequent communication to people in custody and staff explaining what is happening and why is of particular importance.  Protective measures may require additional restrictions, which, if used inappropriately could amount to ill-treatment.  On the other hand, a failure to protect people in custody from contracting a serious infectious disease as a result of lack of preventative measures may also amount to ill treatment.  Therefore, there is a difficult challenge in balancing appropriate preventive measures to ensure they are public health led, proportionate and for the minimum amount of time necessary.

  1. We know people in prison are more likely to experience health issues, and given the close quarters in which people in prison live, it can be difficult to practice preventive measures, such as social distancing. Can you provide some examples of how prisons in Ireland have responded to the current crisis? And, perhaps reflect on the benefits and challenges associated with them?

Prisons in Ireland have adopted a wide range of measures to prevent the entry of COVID-19. The Irish Prison Service (IPS) established an Emergency Response Planning Team (ERPT) to plan and co-ordinate the IPS response to the crisis.  The ERPT established and maintains a close working relationship with the national Public Health Emergency Team (NPHET) and the Health Service Executive (HSE).  The Executive Clinical Lead in the IPS is a Specialist in Public Health medicine and a member of the NPHET Vulnerable Persons Subgroup. In addition to NPHET, the IPS was guided by specific guidance on the management of COVID 19 issued by the Council of Europe and the World Health Organisation. Some of the steps taken include (but not limited to) the following:

  • Reduction in prison population: On 11 March 2020 there were 4,235 people in custody, 343 on temporary release, 784 solely on remand. On 3 June 2020 there were 3,727 people in custody, 392 on temporary release and 730 solely on remand. This indicated a reduction of 508 (12%). In the longer term and post pandemic serious consideration must be given to maintaining and increasing reduction in the prison population.
  • Introduction of basic health screening (5 questions) plus a temperature check of all persons (including staff) prior to entering a prison.
  • Enhanced Communication by provision of weekly newsletters to people in custody and staff. This has been well received and should continue post-pandemic.
  • Establishment of a contract tracing model to ensure prompt identification of contacts of confirmed cases. The WHO has acknowledged the model as best practice.
  • Separation of high risk people from the general population: on 2 June 2020 a total of 263 people were in confinement – 13 in isolation, 130 in quarantine, 120 cocooning. The main challenge is to ensure that these additional restrictive measures are based solely on medical decisions and are in place for the minimum period of time necessary. All newly committed people are quarantined for 14 days in order to reduce the risk that a new committal who might be incubating the virus could spread it to the general prison population. From an oversight perspective it is a challenge to monitor the use of these practices. One prison appeared to have a much higher proportion of people ‘cocooning’ than in other prisons. This led to an Oversight Monitoring Visit and the Inspectorate observation was shared with management and healthcare. The number of people cocooning in the prison concerned has reduced. As the transmission rate of the virus in the general community continues to reduce, the preventative interventions in prisons must be kept under review to ensure proportionality.
  • Suspension of family visits in prisons replaced with virtual video-link visits. This has not been a smooth transition.  The IPS has had to put in place the necessary infrastructure / technology.  It also requires the family member to have access to a smart phone and good quality broadband.  As issues were encountered the IPS put in place measures to address them, e.g. publication of easy read user guides on how to use the system on the IPS website and when this was not sufficient a helpdesk was set up in IPS Headquarters to speak directly with visitors and assist them with their particular issues.

 

  1. With the introduction of strategies to combat the spread of COVID-19, such as limiting contact and increased sanitation requirements, it may be challenging to operate normally during an inspection visit to a prison. What are some of the challenges the Office of the Inspector of Prisons has faced in continuing to monitor during this time?

The OIP is cognisant of the need for enhanced oversight during this time when additional restrictions are being placed on people in custody and prisons are effectively closed to persons other than staff and people in custody. The principal of ‘do no harm’ is placed to the forefront of all activities. When in prison the Inspectorate adheres to the relevant public health advices; social distancing measures are adhered to, conversations with prisoners and staff take place, in as far as possible in open areas. When in offices, social distancing is employed.  Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is worn in accordance with the relevant guidance for staff which is public health led by NPHET. Frequent handwashing or use of hand sanitisers is also employed. As the team is small in number, visits are limited to one person and this of course does impact upon the number of prisons that can be visited.

 

  1. Over the past few months, we have seen international and national prison oversight bodies work to develop best practice standards to ensure inspection in prisons is conducted safely and effectively. What steps has the Office of the Inspector of Prisons taken to ensure monitoring can continue, and to ensure that both inspectors and those in prison are protected while this work is carried out?

Our oversight monitoring activities during this time include both onsite and remote activities as follows:

  • All prisons have received a short (1 day) visit. Regime management was reviewed with a specific emphasis on ‘out of cell time’ and provision of meaningful human contact.
  • Three days (3) were spent in one prison. The prison concerned had categorised nearly 50% of the population as vulnerable to contracting COVID-19. The Inspectorate had the opportunity to meet with the people in custody and staff and review relevant documents/records over the course of the three days.
  • When in prisons PPE was worn when appropriate and social distancing was maintained.
  • In order to capture the ‘lived experience’ of persons being cocooned a journal was issued to 88 people in 7 prisons. The Irish Red Cross volunteers in prisons assisted us with dissemination. 49 Journals are currently being analysed.

  • We receive a daily update from the IPS which provides information relating to the following:
    • The number of confirmed cases in prisons (0 at time of writing this report)
    • Number of confirmed staff cases
    • Prison Numbers
    • Number of suspected cases/isolation in prisons
    • Ongoing actions (includes information regarding the initiatives undertaken by the IPS to mitigate the impact of the temporary cessation of visits in prisons)
    • Summary of staffing in prisons
  • I link in by phone with the Director General of the IPS every 7 -10 days
  • My colleagues contact the Governor in each prison to receive a verbal report approximately every two weeks.
  • We receive copies of the following from the IPS:
    • Copies of the information leaflets provided to prisoners and staff
    • Copies of the algorithms in use within the IPS that outline the steps to be taken with the various cohorts of prisoners within prisons. The algorithms are based on the advices of the National Public Health Emergency Team (NPHET)
  • Activity data (at a point in time, i.e. one week in May 2020) relating to all prisons regarding
    • family video-link visits,
    • Solicitors Conference calls via video link
    • Calls to the IPS Support Line (Chaplaincy, Healthcare, Psychology and IASIO (Irish Association for Social Inclusion Opportunities)
  • Other sources of information received by the OIP are promptly followed up directly with the prison concerned, e.g. phone calls or letters from family members, letters / emails from prisoners or their legal representatives.

We are aware of the guidance regarding monitoring of places of detention from a range of international bodies and we also link in with colleagues in other jurisdictions to share experiences and methods.

 

  1. One of the strategies the Irish Prison Service has taken to prevent transmission of COVID-19 in prisons is to stop in-person visits, which have been replaced by virtual visits for family and friends. As one of the few people permitted to access prisons during this time, can you share some thoughts on how people living and working in prison are coping with the pandemic?

From the Journals of the people who have been cocooning that I have reviewed to date, it can be seen that communication has been important with one person saying “…we are still well-informed, another info sheet from the IPS, encouraging us to keep our minds busy – not too difficult for me.  I still do a bit of French each morning.  These advice sheets are very useful.”  “ I have 6 leaflets from IPS re the virus.  Communication is very good, explaining why normal prison routine has been so drastically changed.”

The mental health effects also come across, with some coping better than others and some using humour to get by – “The lockdown continues. Some are getting a bit cross.  Small niggles take on a new meaning for some and grow out of all proportion. Its to be expected within a group under pressure.  Lockdown rather suits me.  I’m used to living on my own.  I have no one to phone or any visitors to miss.  Its getting released that bothers me.  Must be worse outside, a sunny week-end, no pubs, no beach, no shopping trip.  I’ll just stay here!”(sic)

 

Some understand being cocooned as a protection and others as punishment – “ My punishment by the courts was prison, now doing my punishment cocooning is like doing my time in solitary confinement.  Being punish now for having a chronic, obstructive, pulmonary disease.” (sic)

“I have served three years of a Thirteen year sentence, sinse I have moved to a single cell, I find it great living alone.  Being seventy and always living with someone, is not a happy situation, and I found it more and more difficult”. (sic)

“I realise prison service is doing its best, and the priority is in preventing us oldies catching the virus, for which we must be thankful.   When will it end?”

 

Some of the prisoners also spoke about how difficult it is for staff:            “Officers of the XXX have to deal with it both at home and in prison, so they are on the front line all the time.  The go about there duties well, and mostly with a smiley face.” (sic)

“…this is a hard time not only for prisoners, but even more so for prison offciers, who not only have their family life totally disrupted, but also have a heavy workload for the limited amount of officers who come in daily to keep the ship afloat……..”(sic)

 

 

“Before the Caronavirus outbreak, the Medic’s were very good at there job, and carried out their duties well.  Since Covid 19, all the medical staff, have been “Top Drawer” and should be Recommended for some sort of medal.  The way they go about their business is a sight to behold.”(sic)

“ Several different medical staff do their duties without complaint, from week to week with a kindly smile on their face.  I know this sounds strange, to the suits outside, but for anybody outside who knows how it feels to be cocooned for so long smiley faces mean a lot.”

 

Ask an Expert: Monitoring of Prisons during the Covid-19 pandemic, with Patricia Gilheaney, Inspector of Prisons, Ireland.

In the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, prisons pose a particularly challenging environment in which to prevent the spread of disease. Therefore, the oversight of prisons is an important strategy to ensure rights are respected and that efforts taken to prevent and minimize spread of disease are necessary, proportionate, respectful of human dignity and restricted in time. In Ireland, the Office of the Inspector of Prisons, led by Chief Inspector Patricia Gilheaney, has been instrumental to monitoring the prison response to the threat of COVID-19. The Office of the Inspector of Prisons has been a statutory body in Ireland since 2007 and is responsible for monitoring all of the prisons in Ireland, as well as investigating deaths in custody. PRILA had the great opportunity to ask Chief Inspector Gilheaney about her experience of oversight in relation to Irish prison responses to Covid-19, and how her role has adapted to ensure that the rights of those in custody are protected during this time. Given that prison oversight during the pandemic is a significant challenge, we appreciate the insight and reflections Inspector Gilheaney provides here about her experience.

  1. Since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, organisations such as the WHO and Penal Reform International have highlighted the urgent need to implement effective protections and preventative measures in places of detention. What makes prison a challenging environment when it comes to the management of COVID-19?

There is copious evidence regarding the prevalence and spread of infectious diseases in congregated settings.  Prisons provide an ideal setting for the spread of such diseases due to large numbers of people living in congregated cramped conditions. A high proportion of people in prisons are also considered to be vulnerable due to their age and poor health status. Therefore there are challenges in providing single cell accommodation, social distancing measures, clean environments, access to meaningful interactions with others, visits from family members; access to education/work/training.  The ‘usual’ routine in a prison is completely changed very quickly and frequent communication to people in custody and staff explaining what is happening and why is of particular importance.  Protective measures may require additional restrictions, which, if used inappropriately could amount to ill-treatment.  On the other hand, a failure to protect people in custody from contracting a serious infectious disease as a result of lack of preventative measures may also amount to ill treatment.  Therefore, there is a difficult challenge in balancing appropriate preventive measures to ensure they are public health led, proportionate and for the minimum amount of time necessary.

  1. We know people in prison are more likely to experience health issues, and given the close quarters in which people in prison live, it can be difficult to practice preventive measures, such as social distancing. Can you provide some examples of how prisons in Ireland have responded to the current crisis? And, perhaps reflect on the benefits and challenges associated with them?

Prisons in Ireland have adopted a wide range of measures to prevent the entry of COVID-19. The Irish Prison Service (IPS) established an Emergency Response Planning Team (ERPT) to plan and co-ordinate the IPS response to the crisis.  The ERPT established and maintains a close working relationship with the national Public Health Emergency Team (NPHET) and the Health Service Executive (HSE).  The Executive Clinical Lead in the IPS is a Specialist in Public Health medicine and a member of the NPHET Vulnerable Persons Subgroup. In addition to NPHET, the IPS was guided by specific guidance on the management of COVID 19 issued by the Council of Europe and the World Health Organisation. Some of the steps taken include (but not limited to) the following:

  • Reduction in prison population: On 11 March 2020 there were 4,235 people in custody, 343 on temporary release, 784 solely on remand. On 3 June 2020 there were 3,727 people in custody, 392 on temporary release and 730 solely on remand. This indicated a reduction of 508 (12%). In the longer term and post pandemic serious consideration must be given to maintaining and increasing reduction in the prison population.
  • Introduction of basic health screening (5 questions) plus a temperature check of all persons (including staff) prior to entering a prison.
  • Enhanced Communication by provision of weekly newsletters to people in custody and staff. This has been well received and should continue post-pandemic.
  • Establishment of a contract tracing model to ensure prompt identification of contacts of confirmed cases. The WHO has acknowledged the model as best practice.
  • Separation of high risk people from the general population: on 2 June 2020 a total of 263 people were in confinement – 13 in isolation, 130 in quarantine, 120 cocooning. The main challenge is to ensure that these additional restrictive measures are based solely on medical decisions and are in place for the minimum period of time necessary. All newly committed people are quarantined for 14 days in order to reduce the risk that a new committal who might be incubating the virus could spread it to the general prison population. From an oversight perspective it is a challenge to monitor the use of these practices. One prison appeared to have a much higher proportion of people ‘cocooning’ than in other prisons. This led to an Oversight Monitoring Visit and the Inspectorate observation was shared with management and healthcare. The number of people cocooning in the prison concerned has reduced. As the transmission rate of the virus in the general community continues to reduce, the preventative interventions in prisons must be kept under review to ensure proportionality.
  • Suspension of family visits in prisons replaced with virtual video-link visits. This has not been a smooth transition.  The IPS has had to put in place the necessary infrastructure / technology.  It also requires the family member to have access to a smart phone and good quality broadband.  As issues were encountered the IPS put in place measures to address them, e.g. publication of easy read user guides on how to use the system on the IPS website and when this was not sufficient a helpdesk was set up in IPS Headquarters to speak directly with visitors and assist them with their particular issues.
  1. With the introduction of strategies to combat the spread of COVID-19, such as limiting contact and increased sanitation requirements, it may be challenging to operate normally during an inspection visit to a prison. What are some of the challenges the Office of the Inspector of Prisons has faced in continuing to monitor during this time?

The OIP is cognisant of the need for enhanced oversight during this time when additional restrictions are being placed on people in custody and prisons are effectively closed to persons other than staff and people in custody. The principal of ‘do no harm’ is placed to the forefront of all activities. When in prison the Inspectorate adheres to the relevant public health advices; social distancing measures are adhered to, conversations with prisoners and staff take place, in as far as possible in open areas. When in offices, social distancing is employed.  Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is worn in accordance with the relevant guidance for staff which is public health led by NPHET. Frequent handwashing or use of hand sanitisers is also employed. As the team is small in number, visits are limited to one person and this of course does impact upon the number of prisons that can be visited.

  1. Over the past few months, we have seen international and national prison oversight bodies work to develop best practice standards to ensure inspection in prisons is conducted safely and effectively. What steps has the Office of the Inspector of Prisons taken to ensure monitoring can continue, and to ensure that both inspectors and those in prison are protected while this work is carried out?

Our oversight monitoring activities during this time include both onsite and remote activities as follows:

  • All prisons have received a short (1 day) visit. Regime management was reviewed with a specific emphasis on ‘out of cell time’ and provision of meaningful human contact.
  • Three days (3) were spent in one prison. The prison concerned had categorised nearly 50% of the population as vulnerable to contracting COVID-19. The Inspectorate had the opportunity to meet with the people in custody and staff and review relevant documents/records over the course of the three days.
  • When in prisons PPE was worn when appropriate and social distancing was maintained.
  • In order to capture the ‘lived experience’ of persons being cocooned a journal was issued to 88 people in 7 prisons. The Irish Red Cross volunteers in prisons assisted us with dissemination. 49 Journals are currently being analysed.
  • We receive a daily update from the IPS which provides information relating to the following:
    • The number of confirmed cases in prisons (0 at time of writing this report)
    • Number of confirmed staff cases
    • Prison Numbers
    • Number of suspected cases/isolation in prisons
    • Ongoing actions (includes information regarding the initiatives undertaken by the IPS to mitigate the impact of the temporary cessation of visits in prisons)
    • Summary of staffing in prisons
  • I link in by phone with the Director General of the IPS every 7 -10 days
  • My colleagues contact the Governor in each prison to receive a verbal report approximately every two weeks.
  • We receive copies of the following from the IPS:
    • Copies of the information leaflets provided to prisoners and staff
    • Copies of the algorithms in use within the IPS that outline the steps to be taken with the various cohorts of prisoners within prisons. The algorithms are based on the advices of the National Public Health Emergency Team (NPHET)
  • Activity data (at a point in time, i.e. one week in May 2020) relating to all prisons regarding
    • family video-link visits,
    • Solicitors Conference calls via video link
    • Calls to the IPS Support Line (Chaplaincy, Healthcare, Psychology and IASIO (Irish Association for Social Inclusion Opportunities)
  • Other sources of information received by the OIP are promptly followed up directly with the prison concerned, e.g. phone calls or letters from family members, letters / emails from prisoners or their legal representatives.

We are aware of the guidance regarding monitoring of places of detention from a range of international bodies and we also link in with colleagues in other jurisdictions to share experiences and methods.

  1. One of the strategies the Irish Prison Service has taken to prevent transmission of COVID-19 in prisons is to stop in-person visits, which have been replaced by virtual visits for family and friends. As one of the few people permitted to access prisons during this time, can you share some thoughts on how people living and working in prison are coping with the pandemic?

From the Journals of the people who have been cocooning that I have reviewed to date, it can be seen that communication has been important with one person saying “…we are still well-informed, another info sheet from the IPS, encouraging us to keep our minds busy – not too difficult for me.  I still do a bit of French each morning.  These advice sheets are very useful.”  “ I have 6 leaflets from IPS re the virus.  Communication is very good, explaining why normal prison routine has been so drastically changed.”

The mental health effects also come across, with some coping better than others and some using humour to get by – “The lockdown continues. Some are getting a bit cross.  Small niggles take on a new meaning for some and grow out of all proportion. Its to be expected within a group under pressure.  Lockdown rather suits me.  I’m used to living on my own.  I have no one to phone or any visitors to miss.  Its getting released that bothers me.  Must be worse outside, a sunny week-end, no pubs, no beach, no shopping trip.  I’ll just stay here!”(sic)

Some understand being cocooned as a protection and others as punishment – “ My punishment by the courts was prison, now doing my punishment cocooning is like doing my time in solitary confinement.  Being punish now for having a chronic, obstructive, pulmonary disease.” (sic)

“I have served three years of a Thirteen year sentence, sinse I have moved to a single cell, I find it great living alone.  Being seventy and always living with someone, is not a happy situation, and I found it more and more difficult”. (sic)

“I realise prison service is doing its best, and the priority is in preventing us oldies catching the virus, for which we must be thankful.   When will it end?”

Some of the prisoners also spoke about how difficult it is for staff:            “Officers of the XXX have to deal with it both at home and in prison, so they are on the front line all the time.  The go about there duties well, and mostly with a smiley face.” (sic)

“…this is a hard time not only for prisoners, but even more so for prison offciers, who not only have their family life totally disrupted, but also have a heavy workload for the limited amount of officers who come in daily to keep the ship afloat……..”(sic)

“Before the Caronavirus outbreak, the Medic’s were very good at there job, and carried out their duties well.  Since Covid 19, all the medical staff, have been “Top Drawer” and should be Recommended for some sort of medal.  The way they go about their business is a sight to behold.”(sic)

“ Several different medical staff do their duties without complaint, from week to week with a kindly smile on their face.  I know this sounds strange, to the suits outside, but for anybody outside who knows how it feels to be cocooned for so long smiley faces mean a lot.”

 

Trinity Long Room Hub Covid 19 series: COVID-19 Crisis Blog: Prison and the Pandemic Combatting the Spread of Covid-19

Ciara O’Connell, Sarah Curristan and Sophie van der Valk have published a blog with Trinity Long Room Hub as part of their COVID-19 Crisis Blog series. The blog discusses the challenges and steps being taken within the prison service to combat Covid-19.

You can read the blog here: https://www.tcd.ie/trinitylongroomhub/media/news/articles/2020-05-19-Prila-Blog.php

Prison Oversight in International & National Context: Dynamics, Dilemmas and Opportunities

Christine Morgenstern

On 2 April 2020 the first PRILA workshop was held to present and discuss findings from the work packages on international prison oversight – due to the CoViD 19-related situation this was moved to an online format. The workshop brought together more than a dozen practitioners and academics who work in, experience and/or research prison oversight. Participants, including the PRILA team, came from nine different European countries. Among them were representatives from national and international inspection bodies and NGOs such as the U.N. Subcommittee on Prevention of Torture (SPT), the U. N. Working Group on Arbitrary Detention, the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT), the Irish and Northern Irish Inspector of Prisons, the Irish Prison Reform Trust (IPRT) and the International Committee of the Red Cross. For further information on participants see the PRILA website.

In her introductory comments, Prof Mary Rogan, Principal Investigator of the project, reminded the participants of the objectives of this part of the PRILA project, which include not only a legal analysis of the legal and policy frameworks of prison oversight, but also the exploration of the experiences of those who work in oversight bodies and those affected by prison oversight – namely prisoners and prison staff. To this end, the PRILA team had the excellent opportunity to collect data as a team led by Dr Ciara O’Connell during a CPT visit to Ireland in September 2019. Dr Ciara O’Connell presented some of the findings from Ireland and also from her research in Scotland and Norway, where prisoners and prison staff reflected on recommendations made following recent visits by the CPT. Presentations by Dr Eva Aizpurua on how Prison Oversight Bodies in the EU make recommendations to the Members States and by Prof Mary Rogan on the implications of these research findings for oversight bodies followed. They provided enough stimulation for a very lively and engaging discussion – a great experience not only with regard to the topic, but also for any cyber-sceptic who may have feared that it would be hard to participate in such an online workshop.

For me, being the researcher responsible for the German part of the study, one of the big issues and really illuminating was the discussion of the concept of “complementarity” of different prison oversight mechanisms. I had often wondered about their coexistence and perhaps competition – thinking of Germany, a federal state which has regional differences in terms of oversight and different definitions of what counts as a proper oversight body, a prison governor may be confronted with up to four national institutions (plus the special chambers in the courts who deal with individual prisoner complaints) and five international bodies (including the National Preventive Mechanism); all of them may ask for reports and statements and visit the prison. One of the “take-away messages” from the discussion therefore was that there is a good reason for the multitude of oversight bodies, but that the different mandates and the complimentary functions must be made clearer to those affected, namely to senior prison staff and prisoners. Without clear information on the differences in roles, unrealistic expectations can lead to frustrations amongst those working and held in prison.

A related point are the expectations raised by any visit or even the existence of an inspection body – for a prisoner, any human rights body that visits his or her prison may be seen as a body that is there to defend his or her rights and it may be hard to understand that the mandate perhaps does not cover “everyday prison problems” but rather aims at convincing policy makers and other elites to change their attitudes in certain regards. This is also true for prison staff who, as the Irish findings show, sometimes are unhappy with the impression that positive developments are not valued; and the perception that bodies tend to look for abuse and extremes. This may even amount to a question of “inspection ethics” that have to bear in mind the impact a visit has on those that are subject to the procedure and may feel under intense pressure. The project results will enable us to not only analyse where mandates and oversight work from the different bodies complement each other, where they overlap, where they perhaps even collide; factoring in systemic effects of the inspection works on penal policy and politics as well as the jurisprudence by human rights courts like the European Court of Human Rights or the German Federal Constitutional Court. They will also take into account – as remarkably shown during the workshop – the lived experience of prison oversight and how it may or may not contribute to the credibility and overall goal of the endeavour of oversight: to ensure the respect of dignity and rights of those in prison.

“Mister Complaints”

Christine Morgenstern

Studying this question of prisoner complaints in the German context, I am currently reading a lot of material – older research, court decisions, policy papers and legislative materials. On paper, the German situation looks good: Each of the Prison Acts of the 16 Federal States (Länder) foresees that the prisoner may speak with the prison director (or a representative) regularly, to bring forward complaints, requests or suggestions. This can also be done, at any time, in written form. The prisoner must always get a reasoned answer. If he or she is not happy with the outcome, s/he has several options to take a complaint further, for example to the Ministries of Justice of the Länder as the higher prison authorities or – what is regarded as a particularly powerful tool – to a specialised court (Strafvollstreckungskammer). Of course, it is our research task now to see how this system works in practice!

What currently strikes me as remarkable is – despite the general acceptance of the prisoner’s right to complain – the recurring theme of the ‘troublemaker’, ‘Mr. Complaint’ or, as in the German language use, the Querulant. In all the literature, reference is made to this type of  prisoner who makes multiple complaints and nags both prison staff and courts. In discussing the research with prison officials at the ministerial level responses were given such as “You will see – it is always the same people who complain and keep staff busy”. The topic seems to be rooted so deeply in the discussion that courts sometimes seem to feel the need to make sure that a complainant is not a ‘querulous person’, even if he has multiple queries and regularly fights against prison decisions.

But what is a Querulant? In the decision mentioned the court described a querulous prisoner as one “who delves into judicial matters to avoid grappling with his shallow personality” which, according to this court (and unlike in the case considered), happens very often and may speak against early release and prison leave in later decisions (Kammergericht Berlin, 14th April 2010, 2 Ws 8, 9/10). There is, however, no legal definition for a Querulant and very different interpretations exist. The law is generally very reluctant to rule out multiple complaints. In the drafting procedure of the (former) Federal Prison Act in the 1970s the Association of Prison Staff demanded restrictions on the possibilities to complain (for example by excluding multiple complaints in the same matter or by making prisoners pay certain fees) but no regulations of this kind have been adopted. There is, however, a general ‘prohibition of abuse’: Neither the court nor the prison administration must deal with complaints that clearly have no other aim than to keep them busy without any justification. A restriction can also be found in administrative provisions for the prisons: Requests or complaints that “according to form or content do not fulfil the usual requirements of communications with the authorities” or that contain only repetitions of earlier requests do not have to be heard. These regulations are comparable to the reference to ‘vexatious’ complaints in the Irish system. While in Germany very few court decisions are published in which courts rejected complaints on the grounds of being vexatious, it is unclear, how often prisons internally use this argument. There is, however, consensus in the literature that the administrative provision mentioned must be used with caution, because prisoners often may not know how to properly phrase a complaint and should not be excluded on the basis of their word choice. In any case it is the complaint, not the prisoner that should come under scrutiny.

Nevertheless, the literature review suggests that in practice there is great concern not so much for a type of vexatious complaints but a type of “vexatious prisoner”. Often it is argued that they steal precious time, taking it away from more worthwhile activities in the prisons. And even if this type of prisoner may have good cause to complain and that these efforts may just be an adaptive strategy in prison, there is a certain risk that prisoners who have been labelled Querulant could have great difficulties in being heard later, as all their complaints may be written off as vexatious. One of the few German empirical studies that focused on questions of complaints (Diepenbruck 1981) indeed found that prison administrations were quickly willing to nominate ‘querulous prisoners’ for the sample. In his analysis, Diepenbruck tried to characterise different types of complainants. Of those who complain often, he distinguishes between different types. Some, according to his findings, do so because they feel provoked and feel that they constantly have, at least subjectively, a legitimate cause – they tend to act impulsively and sometimes pursue their goal with a certain aggressiveness. Another type specialises in legal matters both to kill time and to keep prison officials and courts busy, perhaps also to annoy them. As this type studies legal materials, complaints are frequently successful (more often than those of the aggressive type) and may even have positive outcomes for other prisoners.

Only very few prisoners, according to Diepenbruck’s findings, are querulants in the psychiatric sense. Such a diagnosis includes a persistent and obsessive feeling of being wronged and the need to permanently demand justice without having a reason; to a degree that these persons’ lives (and that of relatives) become consumed by their legal battles. Currently, the internationally accepted classifications of illnesses mention querulous behaviour as type of a disorder among the “other persistent delusional disorders” (ICD-10, F 22.8) and as a type of paranoid disorders (F. 60). They are very rarely diagnosed. Calling somebody a querulant therefore is clearly stigmatizing and is hardly justified from a legal point of view and even less so from a psychiatric perspective.

What does this mean for our research? It will be interesting to see whether prison administrations present multiple complainers as ‘vexatious complainants’ or more matter-of-factly. We should also not forget that the group that is noisy and tries to grab the attention of officials may be less of a concern than those who are silent because they are vulnerable. They may have serious problems in prisons, worthy of complaining, without being able to articulate those themselves.

Bibiography:

Diepenbruck (1981). Rechtsmittel im Strafvollzug. Göttingen.

Mullen & Lester (2006). Vexatious Litigants and unusually persistent complainants and petitioners: From querulous paranoia to querulous behaviour. Behavioural Sciences and the Law 24: 333-349.

Dr Christine Morgenstern is a Research Fellow in the School of Law at Trinity College Dublin, member of the PRILA research team and responsible for the German part of the study.

Penal Reform International blog on internal prison inspection

Mary Rogan has published a blog with Penal Reform International on internal prison inspections. In the blog, Mary writes about the important contribution which internal forms of prison inspection can make to the protection of human rights, and the need to avoid confining their work to budgetary or auditing-type activities. The blog provides some examples of internal forms of prison inspection and analyses the Mandela Rules  and the European Prison Rules on the subject.

You can read the blog here: https://www.penalreform.org/blog/the-role-of-internal-inspections-in-protecting-human/

Revised commentary to the European Prison Rules: principles on inspection and monitoring

Mary Rogan

The Council for Penological Co-operation (PCCP), of the European Committee on Crime Problems (CDPC) has recently published revised commentary to the European Prison Rules. This revision has been keenly awaited and is necessary in many areas. It has also been announced that a review of the European Prison Rules (EPRs) themselves will also be revised.

The PRILA team made a submission on the need to revise the commentary (and, indeed, the rules) on the area of inspection and monitoring. Mary Rogan, PI, had the pleasure of presenting this work to the PCCP in Strasbourg in November 2018. Our submission recommended, in particular, the need for the powers of inspectors to be explicitly and robustly stated within the commentary, and that this was a particularly notable absence, especially compared with OPCAT and the Mandela Rules.

We also submitted that the commentary should take account of the Bangkok Rules and ensure that there is gender balance on inspection teams. We further advocated for an inclusion of a requirement that there should be a balance of expertise on inspection teams, including medical and legal expertise.

Another recommendation from PRILA was to ensure that governmental inspection should not be confined solely to budgetary or auditing matters, but that all forms of oversight should focus on the promotion of rights and the prevention of ill-treatment.

The PRILA team is very pleased to see the revision to the European Prison Rules, and the following inclusions in particular:

Rule 9. All prisons shall be subject to regular government inspection and independent monitoring.

New commentary: Rule 9 raises the need for inspection and monitoring to the status of a general principle. Independent monitoring of prisons, complemented by governmental inspection, are crucial mechanisms to ensure that the provisions of these rules are respected. The objective of both inspection and monitoring is to ensure that prisons are managed in accordance with national law, with a view to bringing about the objectives of penal and corrections services, and to protect the rights of prisoners (Nelson Mandela Rule 83.2). The importance of such inspection and monitoring is spelled out further in part VI of the rules.

Rule 92. Prisons shall be inspected regularly by a governmental agency in order to assess whether they are administered in accordance with the requirements of national and international law, and the provisions of these rules.

This rule uses the neutral term “governmental agency”. This agency can be part of one ministry, for example, the ministry of justice or the ministry of the interior, or can be an agency under the control of more than one ministry. The essential point is that such an agency or inspectorate is established by, and reports to, the highest authorities.

The ways in which governmental inspection is organised will vary from checking of the bookkeeping of prisons to in-depth and on-the-spot audits, which take into account all aspects of prison administration to whether what is being done in prison is in conformity with national law. Governmental inspection should not focus narrowly on technical administrative matters. While ensuring that budgeted moneys are well spent is important, its wider obligation is to take into account international law and these rules, as they impact on prison administration. This means that governmental inspection also has to concern itself with ensuring that administrative processes result in prisoners being treated with respect for their human rights. The results of these inspections should be reported to the competent authorities and made accessible to other interested parties without undue delay.

These rules do not specify how planning and control systems and audits should be organised, as this is for the governmental authorities to decide.

Rule 93.1 The conditions of detention and the treatment of prisoners shall be monitored by an independent body or bodies whose findings shall be made public.

Rule 93.2 Such independent monitoring body or bodies shall be encouraged to co-operate with those international agencies that are legally entitled to visit prisons.

In order to ensure that monitoring is truly independent, as required by Rule 93.2, its members shall be experts on prison matters, appointed in a way that ensures their impartiality and seeks to include members with a range of skills, including medical expertise. Due regard should also be paid to gender representation (see Rule 84.2 of the Nelson Mandela Rules and Rule 25.3 of the Bangkok Rules). The monitoring body should be able to propose its own budget directly to the government, so that it is not constrained in this regard by the prison authorities. Monitoring bodies should also have wide authority to access information, choose freely which prisons to visit, conduct private and fully confidential interviews with prisoners and prison staff, and make recommendations on what needs to be done to meet standards set by national and international law. Rule 84.1 of the Nelson Mandela Rules spells out what the scope of such authority should be.

It is important that the findings of these bodies, together with any observations that may have been submitted by the management of the prison concerned, are open to the public. Reports of the monitoring bodies may contain proposals and observations concerning existing or draft legislation. As Rule 85 of the Nelson Mandela Rules specifies, it is reasonable to require that the authorities respond within a reasonable time to such reports and indicate how they intend to implement proposals contained in them.

The European Rules need to be strengthened in the area of inspection and monitoring to consolidate and recognise the good work of the CPT, but also to ensure that they are not lagging behind the protections in OCPAT and under the Mandela Rules. The revision of the EPRs is eagerly anticipated by the PRILA team and all with an interest in this area.