This year’s European Society of Criminology’s Annual conference took place online 10-11 September 2020. Initially planned to be hosted in Bucharest, the Romanian organisers had accepted the task to arrange – together with the ESC Secretariat – the online meeting via one of the many platforms that today enable exchange between all of us affected by the ongoing pandemic. A stringent programme was developed along the existing thematic working groups of the ESC by their chairs, who each organised a stream of panels. More than 700 participants attended – rather: connected to – 116 panels and it was good to see colleagues at least on screen.

The PRILA project found a home in the ESC Working Group on Prisons (https://escnewsletter.org/newsletter/2019-1/esc-prison-working-group) in the panel “Complaints, Rights and Oversight Bodies”. Sophie discussed ‘Patterns and correlates of familiarity with prison oversight bodies among prisoners’, which outlined degrees of familiarity among different groups within the prison population of oversight bodies. Sarah explored ‘The power of prisoner complaint’ as perceived by senior staff. Christine looked at ‘Rules, rights and ethics in prisons as perceived by Senior Staff’ in German prisons (abstracts provided below). The session was completed by Ergul Celiksoy from the University of Nottingham who introduced his research on the ‘Execution of the European Court’s Judgments in Prisoner’s Right to Vote Cases.’ The combination of papers proved to be stimulating (despite our panel being the last of a very long day!), as the audience engaged in a lively discussion. This discussion touched upon the acceptance of court rulings in prison matters (both in the case of the decisions European Court of Human Rights and their impact on national policy, and in domestic cases of judicial oversight); the question of a potential preventive effect of institutional prison oversight and prisoner complaints; and more generally upon aspects of discretion in the work of prison officers. After giving some first insights into our project’s work last year at the ESC conference in Ghent, this panel kept the ‘European Criminology Family’ up-to-date with the PRILA progress and found an attentive audience.
Guess who? Patterns and correlates of familiarity with prison oversight bodies among prisoners (Sophie van der Valk, Eva Aizpurua, & Mary Rogan, Trinity College Dublin)
Oversight bodies play an important role in the protection of prisoners’ rights. While these bodies are seen as widely beneficial demonstrated through the proliferation of bodies and international treaties surrounding them, there is limited research examining them. This study sought to address this gap in the existing literature, by identifying unique profiles of prisoners based on their familiarity with prison oversight bodies. In addition, the relationship between profiles and key factors (personal characteristics, sentence-related variables, and those related to life in prison) was examined using multinomial regression. Participants were 508 males randomly selected from three medium-security prisons in Ireland. Data were collected between November of 2018 and February of 2019 using self-administered surveys. Latent class analysis revealed four subgroups of prisoners characterized by distinct patterns of awareness and contact with prison oversight bodies: 1) Low familiarity (43.9%), 2) High awareness with low contact (26.4 %), 3) High familiarity with the Visiting Committees but low with other oversight bodies (14.4%%), and 4) High familiarity (15.4%). Notably, the largest group was the low familiarity group, and few prisoners belonged to the high familiarity group. Nationality, sentence length, confidence in staff and complaint usage were linked to class membership. The results of this study point to the importance of increasing awareness of oversight bodies among prisoners in general. Also, differences in the composition of the classes provide additional information to target policy and prevention strategies. These findings are of interest to those working on complaints/grieving procedures, but also more broadly to those interested in how prison oversight is experienced by those these structures are designed to protect.
‘Imagine… A Person Listening to You?’: The Power of Prisoner Complaint (Sarah Curristan & Mary Rogan, Trinity College Dublin)
Prison work is a profession that ascribes its occupants a considerable degree of power over those in their charge. Prisoner complaint mechanisms are a vital means by which prisoners can express grievances regarding prison conditions, treatment, or decisions that affect their experience while in custody. As such, the complaints system is one forum through which the prison as an institution can be called to account by prisoners; it is a means for the disempowered to exert a check – however minimal – on the powerful and to express perceived injustice. Drawing on interviews with prison managers from the Irish Prison Service, this research explores the concept of complaint as a form of power. Through a discussion of responsibilities for handling complaints, this paper will describe the stark contrast of perspectives shared by prison staff. For some, complaints are recognised as an essential means for prisoners to voice dissatisfaction, but for others complaints are viewed through the lens of their destructive potential. This perception is one that persists despite the low rate of complaints that are successfully upheld. Further research on how complaints are treated by prison authorities is required, particularly an examination of the efficacy of such procedures. This research presents a starting point for such discussion in examining staff attitudes to complaint.
“One always looks for a compromise…” – Rules, rights and ethics in prisons as perceived by Senior Staff (Christine Morgenstern, Sarah Curristan, Eva Aizpurua & Mary Rogan, Trinity College Dublin)
German prison legislation is praised as comprehensive, based on a fundamental rights approach (van Zyl Smit/Snacken 2009) and prisons are ‘characterized by a highly legalized culture’ (van Zyl Smit 2010). The legislation therefore serves as the frame of reference for all actions and decisions taken in prisons; a special court has the power to review them, if a prisoner appeals to the law. Despite this approach, longstanding criticism refers to the fact that many of the regulations still leave a great deal of discretion to prison staff (Feest/Lesting 2009) and judicial review does not remedy this unpredictability. A more recent initiative calls for a discussion on professional ethics in prisons that could help in situations where the law does not give clear guidance (Becka 2015; 2016; Justizvollzugsbeauftragter NRW 2017). Little is known, however, how senior staff themselves deal with these questions. Drawing on data gained from 24 in-depth interviews conducted in four German prisons between May and December 2019 and a paper survey distributed in February 2020, this contribution explores how senior staff is guided by the legal prescriptions, how far they see them as legitimate and ethical, what they miss and what else enables them ‘to do the right thing’.
